r/classicwow • u/Weltenbaum • 13d ago
Forever Beta Feedback Completely stretched helmets in forever
553
u/KoriKaizen 13d ago
110
12
11
u/Rohbo 13d ago
I'm kind of confused, is this the classic or forever model?
The title makes it sound like this one is the classic, and the "stretched" one is Forever. But then there are a bunch of people acting like the one on the left is so amazing and the one on the right is an atrocity and "how could Blizzard ship it like this?"
I'm just so confused.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (6)5
623
u/EffectiveSwimming136 13d ago edited 13d ago
109
42
33
u/Naclsack 13d ago
To be fair I don't see how someone can look at this and not think its fucken excellent.
Can we keep this one?
→ More replies (1)19
→ More replies (6)7
121
103
u/RedGrobo 13d ago
Important to remember the footman style helm on the right is iconic, and say what you will it feels off to have its shape changed.
→ More replies (9)81
u/GenderJuicy 13d ago
10
u/Kobusc2 13d ago
¿That's a footman? it looks like a champion or knight
13
4
u/Gefarate 13d ago
Nah youre correct. This is the "elite" version. This is the closest thing we have to WC3 footman. The "middle" version. The elite helm is used in the cinematics though
https://wow.zamimg.com/uploads/screenshots/normal/718240.jpg
921
u/MilkyTeaFTW 13d ago
This looks awful lol. I get why people see this as a big issue, the way my character looks is a big part of my enjoyment for the game.
188
u/Front-Investigator68 13d ago
Perfectly put. The looks of the character I’m staring at 99% of the time I play this game is really important to me lol
→ More replies (8)63
u/LCDCMetaux 13d ago
Yeah that’s why I don’t play troll cuz I don’t like these big ass feet lmao
→ More replies (2)52
u/KingPalleKuling 13d ago
Let them dogs out man, ankle warmers are life.
5
13
3
u/LCDCMetaux 13d ago
I’m fine with them being like this ! I don’t play them but I don’t want it changed
24
u/Randvek 13d ago
People who care about what their character looks like aren't rolling Dwarf,
49
6
u/Littlederp_ 13d ago
HD dwarves actually look good ngl, and I say that as a long time Dwarf hater
2
5
2
→ More replies (1)2
→ More replies (4)21
u/vanguardk 13d ago
I've never played wow, so it might suprise you to know they both look awful, hope this helps.
26
u/Legacypicker 13d ago
I dont play wow and the one on the right isnt anything crazy good, but its fine. While the one on the left is comically bad.
→ More replies (4)6
u/_WhiskeyPunch_ 13d ago
Played wow for a very long time, and yeah, both look awful. Why would you ever put this helmet on a dwarf anyway?...
26
358
u/Kman1427 13d ago
138
39
34
24
8
6
2
375
u/AppearanceLiving3406 13d ago
Juggernaut vs Magneto ah post
34
→ More replies (1)2
34
u/OpinionDude5000 13d ago
I demand that our beards show in all their glory!
Ngl, Helms always looked terrible on Dwarves because they never incorporate the beard!
7
u/bronzekobold 13d ago
Aye if left helm leads to seeing the uncropped beard I think that's be a major win.
99
u/ShoulderpadInsurance 13d ago
They really need to just abandon these models and bring back the originals if we’re going to run into issues like this constantly.
Floating shields and meth faces…
→ More replies (4)
11
u/ZombieMarkTwained 13d ago
Jesus that's the helm from RFD right?
Why did they change the model at all?
54
u/_leeloo_7_ 13d ago
one is shaped like a combat helmet the other... lets just say its a good job its not pink
(now I can't unsee it)
6
u/RazekDPP 13d ago
Time to put on your special helmet like in the PBF comic, small man. (NWS) https://pbfcomics.com/comics/small-man/
4
53
u/Desperson 13d ago
Almost like the SD models were an afterthought and not planned for the game
56
u/Brocolo 13d ago
Its crazy to me that they were fully prepared to release classic plus with retail models and be like, yep, this is exactly what people want
31
u/josoda667 13d ago
Yep and other people on this sub will call you an asshole for being skeptical of the dev team despite facts like this existing. Like cool I appreciate you guys sort of fixed it but if we’re being real why did you fuck it up to begin with
→ More replies (3)18
u/Honest_Radio5875 13d ago
There are some silly complaints on this sub, but this one...this is one is pretty damning. Why did it take feedback so late in development to come to the conclusion that classic models would be important to classic+...
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (10)12
u/ChapterDifficult593 13d ago
I mean, I see the idea behind it. If Classic+ is supposed to be a reimagined and updated version of Classic it makes sense that they'd have new models.
Whether or not it was the right move is up to individual taste but the logic is there whether you agree with it or not.
2
u/After_Performer998 12d ago
The logic may be there but it still doesn't make sense when NOT A SINGLE PLAYER from classic has ever said "We want retail models in classic."
It's just an extremely narrow minded decision without any consideration for the community sentiment from the classic players.
3
u/These_Orange9286 13d ago
Having new models is not the same as importing retail models though. The current implementation is just lazy.
4
u/ChapterDifficult593 13d ago
I don't disagree, but I don't see how much different a "new" model could really look from what they've already done in Retail before it stops looking like WoW.
→ More replies (1)
8
6
20
99
u/Gay_If_Read 13d ago edited 13d ago
I genuinely can't tell which one is supposed to be which, they both look terrible.
5
13d ago
[deleted]
2
u/Able-Swing-6415 13d ago
Not surprising. They've made an entirely new video upload ecosystem because people were too stupid to rotate their phones.
→ More replies (1)2
u/iHaveComplaints 13d ago
The most horrifying part of that is that there are now videos originally in landscape with baked in letterboxing for portrait that are then pillarboxed on a landscape display.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)13
10
u/Phreeze83 13d ago
does it depend if you are using HD or SD models?
15
u/Koroklica 13d ago
Pretty sure it will be the same, since the skeleton is the same on both.
2
u/Phreeze83 13d ago
good point, visually i thought there was a slight difference in the forms of the polygons of the head
4
u/OkaZenzo27 13d ago
Welp, it is beta so they could possibly change it before release hopefully...
2
8
u/Mocca_Master 13d ago
That would look great if the beard was visible, which I guess the intention of the change is?
If we disregard the fact that it's actually not showing of course...
3
2
u/ButterBeard_ 13d ago
I had to scroll this far to find someone thinking past 2 second rage. Obv its for the beard
33
u/Talvinter 13d ago
This is why Forever’s HD models can’t just be Retail’s models, if you’re going to have SD then you need new HD to recreate the style in HD.
14
u/DM_ME_KUL_TIRAN_FEET 13d ago
Neither of these are the HD model
17
u/YouAsk-IAnswer 13d ago
Yes, but the SD models use the HD models’ skeletons so you get problems like this.
13
u/LheelaSP 13d ago
If feels like they have put way too much work into reverse engineering the SD models from the HD ones, when they could have just taken the SD models and upscaled them.
Tauren running animation, this helmet, different animations etc. Why reinvent the wheel?
10
u/Wonderful_Reach_4415 13d ago
they didn't reverse engineer anything, they just slapped on the retail models and redid some animations and dragged sd textures over them, did a poor job at it too
4
3
4
4
5
5
5
3
3
3
3
3
u/Enough-Wear-8421 13d ago
Why does the old one look better? The forever one looks like a helmet made for a toddler
3
3
u/LeekypooX 12d ago
Bro on the left looks like the fox Xmen Juggernaut
DON'T YOU KNOW WHO I AM?! IM THE JUGGERNAUT
22
u/Spirited-End5197 13d ago
Which one is which? I have scrolled through this entire thread and nobody has said. Genuinely cant tell because they both look bad
12
7
u/Araetha 13d ago
You can view both on wowhead. Left is Forever, Right is Classic
Forever:
https://www.wowhead.com/forever/item=10763/icemetal-barbute#modelviewerClassic:
https://www.wowhead.com/classic/item=10763/icemetal-barbute#modelviewerSelect Dwarf and you can see the difference. This only happens to Dwarf
11
u/Araetha 13d ago
7
u/Friendly-Ear1721 13d ago
My first ever wow character was a troll warrior in classic. I remember the HUGE disappointment that my 10 year old self had when I realized that helms did not fit properly. Absolutely hated it.
3
→ More replies (4)10
u/IDownvotedYouToday 13d ago
Okay, tusk clipping aside, I do like the Forever version more in this case.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (5)3
u/Jango2106 13d ago
And only for Male Dwarf. Im guessing its 100% a bug and something weird happened to the models
→ More replies (2)3
23
6
u/Escolyte 13d ago
Left is forever, right is classic, I agree though neither is good.
→ More replies (3)21
u/Nurgeard 13d ago
It isn't amazing but Classic's looks like a footmen helmet from original Warcraft - which matters a lot I think, and it baffles me that they would change it.
2
u/Medrilan 13d ago
I don't think they changed it. The skeletons for the character models are the HD skeletons, only the textures change to SD when you enable SD.
This is just a result of the old assets not being made for the new skeletons.
At least thats my understanding.
8
u/AggressiveResist8615 13d ago
What's wrong with the classic one?
5
u/Spirited-End5197 13d ago
Removes beard. But I like it for the fact that it looks like a helmet a unit from wc3 would wear
→ More replies (9)2
→ More replies (58)2
6
6
u/SweetSweetAtaraxia 13d ago
Why does classic look better in every way? Why are they even updating the graphics?
→ More replies (2)14
u/No_Telephone4029 13d ago
Its not, if you don't think the environment looks better your lying to yourself.
→ More replies (2)
2
2
2
u/SnooMarzipans6300 13d ago
looking like a complete bozo clown fits classic perfectly, so left is better for classic
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/joellllll 9d ago
Why is this even a thing? They aren't redoing all the models are they so.. why this specific helmet?
→ More replies (1)
15
u/BaQstein_ 13d ago
I couldn't even tell which one is classic, both look like shit
→ More replies (1)9
u/Squidip1245 13d ago
You’re just lying tho arnt you
→ More replies (2)5
u/BaQstein_ 13d ago
No, not at all. I even bet that if you swap them, 80% of player wouldnt know
→ More replies (3)4
u/Valuable_Berry_8626 13d ago
????????????
80% of players have not seen this helmet model????? This is an extremely common helm model that anybody who has played more than 3 months of classic will recognize.
9
u/MeltBanana 13d ago
Just put vanilla skeletons back in the game already. It's so fucking simple and it's the only fix to all of this.
18
→ More replies (20)6
6
4
u/EggPsychological4844 13d ago
Is that not the Ice metal Barbute? Is there a sub level 30 mail piece that shares this model.
This is so fake lmfao
6
u/canitnerd 13d ago
You know you can just ctrl click to preview gear you can't wear, right?
→ More replies (2)2
u/tordenoglynild666 13d ago
Huh... That's a great point. Unless Forever added a new helm with the same model and botched it.
7
u/Tsobaphomet 13d ago
Idk what AI prompts the devs are using to make the game, but they are doing it wrong
→ More replies (4)
3
u/Metharos 13d ago
Are these people reporting it through the beta's Bug Report function? Or are they just Tweeting like a Twit?
It's a beta. Please report this as a bug.











1.6k
u/Spectshen 13d ago
Its juggernaut!