r/ExpectationVsReality • • 15h ago

Exceeded Expectation Magicarp popsicle

I totally thought the product image was AI and did not expect this to look that well

Edit: I bought this in a Korean convenience store. I just took a screenshot from a Japanese website because it was the first pic I found online.

26k Upvotes

366 comments sorted by

3.3k

u/lisham269 15h ago

I was 100% expecting one of those spongebob abominations.

1.2k

u/radioben 13h ago

130

u/Large-Tree-3666 13h ago

3

u/-teaqueen- 46m ago

🎶🐴wiiild wooomen doooo, and they don’t regret it🐴🎶

255

u/Seraphem666 13h ago

Japan has a law where food on the package has to be the same as what you get Inside the package

101

u/Bugbread 12h ago edited 12h ago

On the one hand, yes.

On the other hand, while the product description is mostly in Japanese, the price is in won, not yen, and the writing on the actual package is Korean, so this is a Korean product and OP's just set their language to Japanese on whatever site they got the image from.

Edit: OP has said elsewhere that the first image is just something they found online, so it's not OP who has set their language to Japanese, but whoever originated the first image.

6

u/BryonBlueCar 9h ago

Possibly a Japanese import to be sold in a Korean store?

9

u/dandroid126 8h ago

This is one of those things that get repeated constantly on reddit. But I went to Japan this last spring and this was definitely not the case. The stuff I bought from the convenience store looked nothing like the packaging.

54

u/Doomsday_Holiday 14h ago

"I was 100% expecting one of those spongebob animations."

11

u/Timely-Cry-8366 14h ago

Same, I was kind of looking forward to how cursed it would probably look 😂

14

u/blueSGL 14h ago

I just want to know how much they cost to make vs these pokemon ones.

It has to be a cost thing that leads to those horror show popsicles

23

u/Muppetude 13h ago

I always assumed storage played a large part in their deformities. Most frozen treats don’t have the same level of detail, so can withstand a few minutes outside the freezer during transport without turning into abominations.

46

u/AlanaYoung1 13h ago

The orange part was the actual ice cream, while all applications like the eye and fins were firmer, like chocolate, so they can't mix with the rest. It also came in a kind of plastic mold with a cardboard box around it 

5

u/blueSGL 13h ago

The cold chain exists for a reason.

Thawing and re-freezing can lead to degraded products and health issues. That goes double for things that are milk based.

19

u/PhillipNoMates 12h ago

I'm sure the dude selling popsicles out of a 40 year old ice cream van has the highest standards

8

u/the_blue_haired_girl 13h ago

Spongebominations

→ More replies (4)

1.6k

u/SkullMaster33 14h ago

Meanwhile in America...

389

u/dmtrme 14h ago

Occasionally remember buying my first SpongeBob ice cream from an ice cream truck in Washington DC back in 2013 during my first trip to USA. I was shook😅

86

u/NKG_and_Sons 13h ago

It appears like some low res photo at first glance.

21

u/dmtrme 13h ago

low res ice cream for sure

35

u/LoganN64 11h ago

I'm old enough to remember when the eyes were gumballs.

4

u/Einermen22 7h ago

Wait, they got rid of the gum balls?!?! Horrible

→ More replies (1)

11

u/TheDogerus 12h ago

I never even liked those stupid popsicles but i was such a big spongebob fan that i would forgo the ice cream i actually wanted for it

6

u/nomnomsoy 8h ago

That's literally the most spongebob looking one I've ever seen

3

u/skromply 10h ago

Yours is kinda cute! 🫠

→ More replies (1)

34

u/carm_aud 6h ago

I always share my photo when people comment about these !!

27

u/BigPecks 12h ago

Why isn't anyone helping him?

3

u/Spyko 7h ago

he said Nobody hurt him, what do you want us to do ?

18

u/QuarkGuy 13h ago

Couldn’t they just rebrand them as minion pops?

7

u/tortapounder14 13h ago

They have those too 😂

9

u/Show-Me-Your-Moves 13h ago

It's Polyphemus!

3

u/Life-Suit1895 12h ago

Polyphemusbob Squarepants

3

u/tsukareneko 14h ago

LMFAOOOOO

2

u/Kurailo 13h ago

Spongob!

2

u/Lady_night_shade 12h ago

Polyphemus!

2

u/CouchHam 13h ago

We get what we deserve

→ More replies (1)

791

u/AlternativeDraw1795 15h ago

I am sorry but there is an imperfection. You should get rid of it.

437

u/Larebear2199 15h ago

See you tomorrow chef

76

u/FYAhole 14h ago

OP has to buy one every day until it's absolutely perfect

17

u/Alexis_0hanian 11h ago

You mean until he gets the shiny

8

u/Pizzacato567 9h ago

Omfg! I’d forgotten about this.

12

u/KalaUposatha 13h ago

The final post will just be a perfect Gyarados popsicle

→ More replies (1)

41

u/Novel_Quality5743 15h ago

The mouth isn’t open either. Highly disappointed.

31

u/Geen_Fang 15h ago

literally inedible 

3

u/GregTheMad 14h ago

Literally uneatable.

5

u/Ok_Medicine_1112 14h ago

It ain't perfect unless it flops around in your mouth

2

u/chocobosROK 9h ago

AHEM brings out magnifying glass The outline of the eye isn’t perfectly circular. The outline around the mouth looks nicked at the bottom. There are tiny craters at the top part of the side and back fins. The bottom yellow fin also has some surface imperfections. Looks like there might be a planar change on the bottom of the eye. There might be another tiny crater at the back of the head where it meets the body on the raised area. Absolute travesty of a popsicle.

→ More replies (2)

403

u/MsAndooftheWoods 14h ago

I just had a pikachu one! It wasn't quite as perfect though.

80

u/DeathRabbi 10h ago

Looks like freezer burn, meaning it was the vendor, not the product that f-ed up.

73

u/yanderia 14h ago

Still very cute tho 🥰

13

u/Archaeellis 14h ago

Where do you buy these?

33

u/MsAndooftheWoods 14h ago

CU convenience stores in Korea! Apparently Pikachu is mango flavored.

12

u/FutureComplaint 14h ago

... Do they ship internationally?

25

u/Lolkimbo 9h ago

Sure, if you enjoy melted mango water.

3

u/oxide_j 13h ago

Right? I want a Swinub on a Stick.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Willing_Dot_5699 14h ago

Looks like in Korea

2

u/Over-Pineapple3833 13h ago

That's almost too cute to eat. 

→ More replies (6)

51

u/Last_Amphibian2117 4h ago edited 3h ago

Omfg I swear maybe it’s cus I’m American but idk how they stay skinny over there I’d b eating all the cute dumb lil snacks they have in Korea 😂🤣

24

u/Mildly_upset_bee 3h ago

They walk a loooooot

2

u/Last_Amphibian2117 3h ago

Ah makes sense guess it’s like Italy with their stairs lol y they can eat all those carbs

2

u/HeadDot141 2h ago

True. I lost a good bit of weight when I started college because I walked to my classes in order to not leave my parking spot lol

439

u/-OhHiJinx- 15h ago edited 13h ago

Japan has a law that requires manufacturer's to have their packaging look identical to the product!

Edit: sorry I saw another comment that said Japanese and made an incorrect assumption that this product was from Japan. Please forgive me!

124

u/Massive_Muffin_7805 15h ago

The box has korean on it. Not that what you said is wrong. The rest is japanese tho too

21

u/MsAndooftheWoods 14h ago

Yeah, they're sold in CU convenience stores in Korea.

3

u/blegoraththewretched 11h ago

I'll CU there.

13

u/Cullyism 14h ago

Feel like this is more important than ever now with how common AI advertising is in so many countries.

6

u/baoball 13h ago

Is a korean product ingeoking -> goldfish-king or smthn the kr name for magikarp

→ More replies (1)

7

u/opajamashimasuuu 13h ago

Fairly sure Japan’s currency symbol is the ¥en. Well, actually I am sure.

But it would be funny if they changed ¥en to  ₩en. 

But they got nothing on the Vietnam Dong, that’s for sure.

But no, these are not a Japanese product at all.

Thanks for coming to my Ted Talk.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

63

u/AnAncientBog 9h ago

The tenancy (and requirement in some cases) of packaging EXACTLY matching the contents in much of Asia is really something you would expect from any consumer focused economy.

17

u/AnnigidWilliams 7h ago

There’s a law in Japan that if a food is shown on a photo on its box, the contents have to match the photo near perfectly.

19

u/LataCogitandi 8h ago

Nah that’s just Japan. The rest of East Asia is mostly also on that “pictures are for reference only/serving suggestion” model.

Source: grew up in Taiwan

9

u/starlightshower 6h ago

This particular product is Korean, though I know of examples of what you mean too.

82

u/AfraidInspection2894 14h ago

I keep seeing comments about Japan and Japanese law when this product is not Japanese. It is Korean. The box has Korean writing on it, the price is in Korean won and the CU next to my apartment in Seoul has these and other PokĂŠmon popsicles for sale

7

u/Electrical-Review180 14h ago

What do they cost?

2

u/Bugbread 12h ago

It has the price right there in the image.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/mr_fucknoodle 11h ago

That's because "Japan has laws to make the product look like it does in the package" is a factoid that made its way around reddit earlier this year, so now every redditor is an expert on this field and will trip over themselves to parrot it, even when it doesn't apply

2

u/kpdeadwolf 7h ago

I’m pretty sure it’s because on mobile the first image is cropped so that half of it shows Japanese text, and the box has white Korean font on light pink so it’s like impossible to see with compression

3

u/Dramatic-Cookie-6636 8h ago

Redditors favorite thing is to parrot or shoehorn in factoids they learned on here. They still haven't figured out that everyone else also reads the same shit they do so it's pointless for them to comment it.

Maybe one day they will get there...

→ More replies (5)

25

u/Ok-Accident3344 6h ago

Sega Does What Nintendon’t!

102

u/xError404xx 15h ago edited 11h ago

Scrolled down and saw a messed up poptart immediately 😂 in japan theres a law that products have to look exactly like advertised.

Edit: the product is apparently bought in korea. I only saw japanese on the website and thought they bought it there.

9

u/baoball 13h ago

That's a korean product

10

u/mynumberistwentynine 13h ago

damn Japanese laws know no bounds

3

u/HairyTeef 13h ago

See, the Japanese need laws to ensure perfection, while the Koreans manage it by nature.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

18

u/Hour-Pipe6955 15h ago

wut did he taste like

17

u/AlanaYoung1 13h ago

Not sure what it was supposed to taste like, but I felt is was kind of blood orange/ citrusy flavored, and the fins and other application were white chocolate. It was surprisingly good!

19

u/TentacleMonsterUwU 7h ago

Meanwhile in America

44

u/RickSanchez_C137 12h ago

The west has lost it's expertise in manufacturing. We don't do enough of it to be good at it anymore. I don't know anyone currently working on manufacturing design or on assembly lines.

Asian countries now have all the skill and creativity when it comes to product and package design.

Westerners are focused on how to make things cheaper with cheaper ingredients and cut corners. Products in Asian markets actually seem to be getting better. This is an especially obvious example, but it's not an outlier.

12

u/niberungvalesti 10h ago

We didn't lose the expertise, we focused on corporate profits to the detriment of everything else. The manufacturers of these products are still profit driven but also have pride in their finished products.

4

u/PartyPorpoise 8h ago

Corporate profits, and American consumers being obsessed with low prices at the expense of other qualities.

6

u/secretsaucyy 8h ago

It's not that asian countries have more skill, they have harsher laws that force them to be more meticulous. There's a law that states that the food product MUST look exactly like the immage on the package. Even the exact same size and texture. They can't cut corners or else they're subject to fines that WILL be collected.

Whereas the US has no such law and they can be as deceptive and predatory as they want with their food. Like Vitamin Water was/still kind of is.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/Osirus1156 9h ago

I love how whimsical everything in Asia seems to be. The US is just turning into a Grey nightmare land thanks to unregulated capitalism and literally zero repercussions for anyone with a $50m net worth or higher. 

6

u/rinkydinkvaltruvien 8h ago

I think people are purposefully missing the point of what you said so that they can feel right. Obviously day-to-day life for people in these countries is not "whimsical." But we're not talking about that, we're specifically talking about about the products available to them vs. the products available to us. So many products - objects we see and interact with daily - have become gray, bland and unfun because of our companies doing the bare minimum. Rather than actively try to appeal to the consumer, the strategy seems to be to kill the competition so the consumer has no choice but to spend their hard-earned money on shitty products.

2

u/vivst0r 7h ago

I think what factures much more into this isn't lack of trying or capitalism, but the prevailing notion of what it means to be an "adult". Which is what mandates everything to be sleek, refined, matured. While anything whimsical is only found in products aimed at children and since they are only for children they don't actually need high quality.

In Japan many things that would immediately be called "childish" in the west are just normal things enjoyed and consumed by adults without stigma. And adults also demand more quality than children for their whimsy. And that's how you get quantity and quality of whimsy in Japan and only grey quality and shoddy whimsy in the west.

Though there's also the generally higher demand for quality particularly for food in Japan.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/immaownyou 9h ago

Calling everything whimsical is just looking at it through rose colored glasses and insanely naive. Really? You think asia isn't affected by unregulated capitalism and zero repercussions for the rich??

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Rasberrycello 9h ago

It's "whimsical" if you're only visiting. Living there, it's got it's share of problems, just like any other country. And I just can't see "whimsy" as being the predominate descriptor for a place that has such a high suicide rate, or a specific word for "Death by overwork."

3

u/National-Charity-435 8h ago

Pretend napping at work is also a thing to show how hardworking you are

While "voluntary" nights out with coworkers will get old real fast if you don't like someone

Team meetings also get old quick + shift rituals (reciting the mission statement)

Then comes the entitled tourists who demand photos or something out of customs despite the worker looking uncomfortable or trying politely to get out of the situation

Of course they get compensated well for this?!

....buddy

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/BeegBunga 8h ago

We do, but our businesses would rather squeeze out 0.0001 cents per Popsicle.

4

u/Euphoric-Sun5317 8h ago

Truly the death of the west... we don't make fancy enough PokÊmon popsicles... 

3

u/Icy_Consequence897 8h ago

They've even started selling ice creams like these here on the West Coast and it's blowing people away. I got a peach ice cream that was not only made with real peaches rather than artificial peach flavor, but it even looked like a 3D realistic peach, on a stick.

They had all sorts of fruits, but at this Pride event, the peach one was selling really well for some reason

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

14

u/Hopeful-Feeling1876 10h ago

It looks perfect!!

9

u/leytonscomet 11h ago

Was it a Korean convenience store actually in Korea or are you in the states?

13

u/AlanaYoung1 11h ago

I'm actually in Korea

→ More replies (3)

28

u/whatdis321 15h ago

All these comments about a law in Japan. Product description is in Japanese, pricing is in South Korean Won, packaging is in Korean?? Unless it’s a Japanese product packaged for the Korean market? But why is the description in Japanese, unless OP is Japanese living in Korea? 😅

10

u/AlanaYoung1 13h ago

I bought these in Korea, I just got the product  screenshot from a Japanese website apparently, because it was the first online pic I found.

15

u/AfraidInspection2894 15h ago

These are sold in Korea! There are a bunch of different PokĂŠmon popsicles for sale not just magicarp. The CU near me has like 3 or 4 different ones. I keep meaning to try them.

5

u/MsAndooftheWoods 12h ago

Yeah, and the actual package is literally just a cartoon anyway, so it wouldn't even follow the Japanese law there are 100 comments about.

2

u/StereoWings7 9h ago

tbf Product description also have Korean text, 잉어킹 소르베., and its transliteration in Japanese katakana インオキン ソルベ, which don’t make sense if it were read as Japanese.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Pink-frosted-waffles 10h ago

What flavor is it?

27

u/mexicant29 10h ago

Fish and dry ice

2

u/Pink-frosted-waffles 10h ago

Oh. That's interesting. I was thinking it would be tropical or something basic like orange cream. Thank you.

22

u/osdanova 10h ago

It is indeed orange. They were just joking.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/starlightshower 6h ago

The magicarp one is orange flavoured, pikachu is mango flavour and there is a ditto one that is grape flavour apparently

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/pi-n-ku 14h ago

Sonic the Hedgehog popsicle I found

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Sleepy_kitty67 5h ago

That is absolutely wonderful looking.

Did it taste ok?

5

u/Iguana_Enthusiast 15h ago

It looks better in real life than in the ad...

17

u/Goryokaku 13h ago

Pretty sure in Japan it's law to make the product appear like it actually does on the packaging. The price was in KRW but the description in Japanese so I'm guessing it's a JP product.

13

u/AlanaYoung1 13h ago

I bought it in Korea, the packaging says made in china. I just took the screenshot from a Japanese website

9

u/Mercenarian 12h ago

That was a ride

2

u/Moon_Salad_84 12h ago

Laughed harder at your comment than I should have.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/KumanderKulangot 15h ago

Totally pathetic, unreliable

4

u/Rude-Friend-9135 4h ago

The only things keeping these stupid popsicles from selling for hundreds of idiot bucks is the fact that they are:

  1. Sold only in Japan

  2. frozen perishable products that can’t be graded by PSA/WATA.

6

u/JayWeed2710 15h ago

TIL that the fin of this pokemon is a crown. Never noticed this

5

u/Hobspon 14h ago

TIL Magikarp japanese name is Koi King. The crown makes sense.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/SkyK025 14h ago

They are called koi-king in Japanese!

2

u/AutumnMama 12h ago

TIL that the crown is actually a crown-shaped fin lol. I thought the guy was just wearing a crown 🤷

13

u/melanie_anne 15h ago

Considering that Japan has very strict regulations on false advertising and food, I'm not surprised. Excited for you nonetheless, OP!! Almost looks too good to eat

→ More replies (2)

6

u/orcusgrasshopperfog 13h ago

I'm genuinely curious to know how exactly this was made.

I don't see any color bleed so it doesn't look like the individual parts are dyed. As in a solid white casting with the required parts dyed.

It almost looks like a multi-part over molding injection mold. 4 part mold with the eye manually placed. Or a five-part mold if the eye is molded as well... That's like between $80k low volume single shot mold to $150k for a high volume multicast mold. Add to that a food safe refrigeration system to flash cool the mold and cooling tunnels you're looking at easily adding another $400k to $650k a cold storage clean room environment for production... For an ice cream. That is absolutely insane.

9

u/AlanaYoung1 13h ago

I have no idea how this was made but only the orange part is ice cream, all the applications had a chocolate - like consistency

3

u/orcusgrasshopperfog 12h ago edited 12h ago

Yeah makes sense. A single shot ice cream mold then flash Frozen and inserted into multi-shot "chocolate like product" injection overmolds.

Either way still an extremely expensive process with a lot of overhead for an ice cream bar. Pokemon really does have selling power eh.

2

u/MsAndooftheWoods 11h ago edited 11h ago

They're sold for a premium too, I guess that's why. Like most ice cream is only ~1,000-2,000 won here, but this is 5,900 won.

2

u/orcusgrasshopperfog 11h ago

Yeah not all that surprising considering they probably had to invest about a million minimum in machinery just to start making these things. With 50% margins, they'd have to sell a half a million of these ice cream bars to break even.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/BeachBrad 12h ago

Individual frozen parts "glued" together. can tell by the tolerances around the fitted parts.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ChampionshipAlarmed 6h ago

I want this so bad now . My favorite Pokemon

3

u/akaispirit 14h ago

"Okay well theres no chance at all it's going to actually turn out like-...Alright, fair enough."

11

u/FecalDUI 10h ago

Idk about Korea but in Japan what’s on the box is what you get by LAW

4

u/jclv 6h ago

With that stick shoved up it's ass, it should be making the same expression as on the box.

3

u/platypus_ringmaster 13h ago

this makes me appreciate how disappointing so much food is in the US. so sick of opening of a package and losing my appetite because it looks nothing like the photo. i wish grocery stores took returns.

2

u/GlenntheManNotaRobot 3h ago

Man I want a Frozen Ingeoking Sorbet pop real bad!

2

u/tenkohime 15h ago

Whoa! Great likeness! 

2

u/glad_goblin 14h ago

That magicarp look like they need a hug

2

u/ssuchan1 14h ago

Genuinely thought it's 5,900 YEN and thought "wtf that's one expensive ice cream", turns out it's krw 😅

2

u/xsake1001 11h ago

Use Splash! it’s super effective against the ice cream truck budget.

2

u/ThorntonText 11h ago

A branded popsicle that actually looks like it's supposed to? Yeah, you definately didn't get that from America. All our popsicles based on IPs looks like Salvador Dali nightmares.

2

u/Nate-2020 10h ago

Been wanting to visit Korea, after reading the comments trying a PokĂŠmon popsicle is so being added to my bucket list

2

u/chamberx2 9h ago

So it wasn't a... flop.

6

u/megatricinerator 8h ago

Japanese food products legally must match the description or visual that's on the box, so no lazy eye popsicles on their watch.

2

u/[deleted] 9h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/kiticat64 8h ago

clanker

3

u/rambogambomogambo 15h ago

❤️ Japanese perfection

11

u/MsAndooftheWoods 14h ago edited 14h ago

It's sold* in Korea ❤️

→ More replies (5)

5

u/wildpen70 14h ago

these are made in China and sold in Korean CU stores

2

u/an_agreeing_dothraki 12h ago

Japan doesn't mess around with this stuff because of their food laws.

12

u/Bugbread 12h ago

This is a Korean product made in China. The Japanese is just because OP grabbed an image from someone looking at a Korean e-commerce site with the store language set to Korean.

1

u/PlasticMegazord 6h ago

I don't like that because I wouldn't want to eat it, it looks too good.

1

u/Shantotto11 6h ago

*Magikarp

1

u/PurpleSwizzleBerry 4h ago

MagiKarpcikle

1

u/TheJonesLP1 3h ago

Damn, thats awesome!

1

u/Successful-House1325 3h ago

Their cartoon ice cream make the US cartoon ice cream look bootleg

1

u/daneylion 46m ago

I actually gasped, I wasn’t expecting it to not be a disaster! That’s awesome!

1

u/Bananaland_Man 11m ago

Holy shit, I can't even...

1

u/Pleasant_Light9725 15h ago

Was it orange flavor?

2

u/turtleneckless001 14h ago

Fish flavour

1

u/TechsSandwich 14h ago

Holy shit

1

u/Archaeellis 14h ago

Where did you buy this?

4

u/AfraidInspection2894 14h ago

CU convience stores in Korea! They also have ditto and Pikachu

1

u/Willing_Dot_5699 14h ago

It's even better than on picture 

1

u/GrowlingPict 13h ago

Well as in healthy or well as in it has good eyesight?

1

u/KalaUposatha 13h ago

It looks worried in the reality version

1

u/hartstyler 13h ago

Thats crazy

1

u/dope_danny 13h ago

The King of Carp never misses.

1

u/TakoyakiGremlin 13h ago

holy shit, that’s immaculate. not like the garbage we have in north america lol

1

u/0x7E7-02 13h ago

Beautiful! What flavor is it?

1

u/gadafgadaf 13h ago edited 13h ago

Yeah all the Disney character ice creams usually look deformed.

1

u/natesnas 13h ago

GulpGulp!

1

u/BIGGREDDMACH1NE 12h ago

I'll take 8

1

u/frozenivy2B 11h ago

That looks cool

1

u/CharmingKitKat 11h ago

It's almost too pretty to eat. I hope it tastes as good as it looks!