r/GetStudying • u/Radiant_Waltz8068 • 6h ago
Question I went from being a top student to struggling in medical school, and I don’t understand what changed
I’m currently in my third year of medical school, and I’m honestly desperate for advice because I’ve been struggling with the exact same problem since first year.
Back in school, I was one of the top students. I had a study method that worked incredibly well for me, and studying was genuinely fun. I could memorize things so well, retain information, and consistently get excellent results without feeling exhausted.
Here’s what I used to do:
I had a lecturer who posted recorded lectures. The exams were based entirely on what he explained, so I knew exactly what I needed to learn. I would listen to the entire lecture, which was usually 1–1.5 hours long and very detailed and fast-paced. I would take notes and include absolutely everything he said. Then I would turn those notes into flashcards by hand and study them.
That was my routine every single day. I loved it, I never got tired of it, and my memory was excellent. I could remember almost everything I studied.
Then I started medical school, and everything fell apart.
Now I study from textbooks like Guyton, Devlin, and Robbins and Cotran. The material is much more extensive, and lecturers obviously cannot explain every single detail during class. I initially thought I just needed time to adapt to university, but I’m now in my third year, and I still have exactly the same problem.
I genuinely feel like my brain doesn’t process textbooks the way it used to process lectures.
I can read a paragraph and understand what it says. I can understand individual concepts. But when I finish reading 20 or more pages, I feel incredibly confused. I struggle to see the bigger picture, I get lost in the details, and it feels like my brain has completely ignored everything I just read.
I end up barely memorizing the core information, while my classmates seem to read the entire textbook chapter, understand it, remember the details, and know everything so well.
What makes this especially frustrating is that I used to outperform many of these same classmates in school. I actually studied more back then because I had so many different subjects, and the lectures were not short or superficial. They were detailed, fast-paced, and required me to remember a lot of information.
So I don’t think the problem is simply that medical school is harder or that there is more material. I suspect something about my study technique is no longer working.
I’ve tried studying only the most important information and breaking the material into smaller sections, but that hasn’t solved the problem either. Even when I study relatively small concepts, I struggle to learn them effectively.
I’ve practically given up on reading textbooks because the process is so confusing and frustrating. I don’t know how to extract the information, organize it in my head, and retain it the way I used to.
I also struggle with understanding how all the details fit together when I’m reading. I can understand individual sentences, but I somehow lose the overall structure of the topic by the time I finish.
I’ve become depressed over this. Going from being a top student to feeling like one of the worst students in my class has seriously affected my self-esteem. I keep comparing myself to my peers and wondering what happened to me.
Has anyone experienced something similar?
I’m particularly interested in hearing from people who found a study method that worked extremely well for them in school but completely stopped working in medical school.
How did you adapt? How do you study from large, detailed textbooks without getting lost in the information? And how do you retain both the big picture and the individual details?
I don’t just want advice like “use active recall” or “try spaced repetition.” I already know about flashcards, and they were actually the foundation of my old study method. The problem is that I can no longer seem to get the same results, even when I try to use similar techniques.
I really want to understand what I’m doing wrong and how to fix it, because I know I’m capable of learning well. I just can’t seem to figure out how to do it anymore.