r/Banking • u/minhash • 4h ago
Advice BECU (WA State) froze my new account and flagged me for fraud, need advice
Timeline of Events:
- Early Oct: Received a generic BECU mailer/promo for a new checking + savings account signup bonus. Submitted an online application
- Oct 12: Account approved
- Oct 15: Received account documentation via mail, configured the BECU mobile app and linked an external bank account to set up external transfers (initiated micro-deposit/account verification)
- Oct 19: Initiated a $100 push transfer from external bank to BECU checking. Also reconfigured my employer's payroll direct deposit to point to the new BECU checking account
- Oct 20: Received BECU debit card in mail. External account transfer link was fully validated and the initial $100 push landed in BECU checking. Initiated a $4,000 ACH pull from BECU pulling from external bank. I tried a $5,000 pull earlier that evening but it failed/was rejected and phone rep suggested the external bank denied it but to try again later
- Oct 21 (Today):
- The $4,000 ACH pull posted to BECU checking
- Received a call from BECU Fraud Ops asking if I had been traveling recently or fell victim to a social engineering scheme. Fraud Ops placed a complete freeze on the account and directed me to visit a local branch to fix the issue. They also told me that they suspected I was working with someone else and to cease all online communications with other third parties about my account
- Visited a BECU branch with drivers ID, debit card and the original promo mailer. Branch representative initially tried to set up a new replacement account and had no concerns up front (including transferring the SUB) but hit a system lock at the end requiring a call to Fraud Ops
- Branch agent spent a while on the phone. I heard mention of "he's here on the pretense of using this signup bonus" along with a lot of "mmmhmms". I was told that my account setup history looked like an ongoing account scam running on social media (like Facebook groups), where someone (from Asia?) would front money for another person signing up for an account on their behalf and then split the signup bonus with the original money fronter. He then asked me multiple questions, including where I got the mailer, how I was signing up, and was I really, 100% not actually working with someone online on social media to setup my bank account (I showed them the mailer again)
- He then told me he couldn't open my new account but assured me nobody would be able to take my money and that I might possibly get ACH access in 5 business days and should hear back from the fraud department in 10 business days but I may be expelled from BECU at that time
Where should I go from here? I've encountered issues in the past signing up for bank accounts where banks would not fulfill the terms of the signup bonus (and had to fight them via BBB and CFPB) but never had my account frozen and accused of being a fraudster. Is this something where I should submit a CFPB, NCUA, State AG, even BBB complaint immediately or should I wait a bit to hear back in two weeks? I can show a complete account history that all of the money I'm getting comes from my own bank account (and by extension, my W2) if that helps. My girlfriend also used the same SUB mailer (it was generic) and hasn't had any issues on her end.