This is a discussion space for everyone, covering everything from world to student trends.
Community Reminders:
* Content Relevance: Ensure your content relates to India or has a documented impact on India within a global context (Rule 1).
* Civil Discourse: No hate speech, identity-based attacks, or harassment (Rule 3).
* No Spam: Do not turn the sub into a personal billboard or dump links without engaging (Rule 4).
Ek NRC and CAA bill ke wajah se Delhi mein riots ho gaye, even now as close as Pahalgam attack, Kashmiri Muslims are being caught for aiding and abetting Pakistani terrorists, do u really think in an all out war for land mass, Indian Muslims across India won’t sabotage army’s efforts?
You won't take Aksai Chin because of the repercussions. Similarly, why would you do the same with PoK when there are great repercussions? You think we won't suffer as a nation if we do try something stupid like that?
I think what's stupider is you going schizo under a comment which said nothing about 'wanting to takeback pok' and even anyone who supposedly might want that would hold the same standards for Aksai Chin, timeline and conditions matter. Stop parroting the same shit and arguing walls.
See, the only resource that u can’t make on the entire planet are wood and land. Why do u think trump is chasing Canada and Greenland? Also, we have the biggest population in the world, we will never have enough land for us. The more land we have the better is it for us.
Again a rage bait. Have you been to Manipur or know anything about it ? Have you ever asked why no opposition leader went there either ? Why no opposition over Bengal where Hindus were lnchd by Ms all through last 10 - 15 years ? Kanihya lal was sl@ghtrd in broad daylight light by Ms. All H were appealed that he didnt tweet or even came in support of his party member.
After all this, know who is adbhakt
Again a rage bait. Have you been to Manipur or know anything about it ? Have you ever asked why no opposition leader went there either ? Why no opposition over Bengal where Hindus were lnchd by Ms all through last 10 - 15 years ? Kanihya lal was sl@ghtrd in broad daylight light by Ms. All H were appealed that he didnt tweet or even came in support of his party member. After all this, know who is adbhakt
Is this supposed to be rage bait by pasting ChatGPT or Gemini response here ?
Hi, whoever you are stop reading from mainstream media and start with independent journals , I am from northeast and things are not at all great in manipur. Bjp did a good infra job in assam but they are trying to put the religious harmony into danger. We northeastern love everyone irrespective of anything. Please stop putting things as if you know what is going on anyway
They are not great in Manipur, why noone is protesting there ? They are asking for resignation of Pradhan , but feel somewlhow Bengal and Manipur are less of a problem? Or are they not funded by foregin establishments to protest against issues that warrant larger and wider protests ?
Protest? Is almost a marshal law scenario if you dnt know how northeastern state and border force work dont comment. Protest need proper stability when a state aren't even functioning how do u expect it to Protest or do anything. If you think foreign funding is present then great job Maybe CBI and home affairs has a good candidate to hire. See i dont care who you are what you stop saying things when you dont know ,I too want my country to be a better place and if you want to argue and point things please learn and argue , stop putting post on things you dont know about.
Took modi 2 years to even step foot there btw. Also why is there expection for Opposition to go in a state that is ruled by BJP on both state and center level? Rahul kabh se elect ho gaya?
Have you ever asked why no opposition leader went there either ?
Multiple opposition leaders visited Manipur after the outbreak of violence in 2023. Rahul Gandhi himself visited relief camps in 2023 and also launched the Bharat Jodo Nyay Yatra.
Additionally, a 21-member delegation of opposition MPs from the I.N.D.I.A bloc visited affected districts in July of 2023 to inspect relief camps and meet displaced families. [hindu article talking about his visit to manipur]
Why no opposition over Bengal where Hindus were lnchd by Ms all through last 10 - 15 years ?
Opposition parties in WB frequently protested, held rallies and approached courts over political and communal violence under TMC adminstration. National media, central fact-finding teams and the NHRC have repeatedly investigated and covered post-poll and communal violence incidents in Bengal.
Kanihya lal was sl@ghtrd in broad daylight light by Ms
Kanhaiya Lal, a tailor in Udaipur, Rajasthan, was murdered by two muslim men (Riyaz Attari and Ghouse Mohammad) over a social media post supporting Nupur Sharma. The murder was widely condemned across the political spectrum, including by opposition leaders who demanded strict punishments. They were promptly arrested post investigation by NIA.
If the issue is so bad, whyare roaches protesting in Delhi and not in Manipur? Ask for his resignation from there or even from Delhi and I will be the first person to suppirt you. Go do it. You won't, because u r not being funded for it. Know how protests start and what and whose agenda they serve.
Rahul Gandhi, the Leader of Opposition has visited Manipur multiple times since the ethnic violence broke out in May 2023:
• First Visit (June 29–30, 2023): He undertook a two-day peace visit, touring relief camps in Churachandpur, Moirang, and Imphal, and meeting the Governor of Manipur.
• Second Visit (January 14, 2024): He launched his Bharat Jodo Nyay Yatra from Imphal in Manipur.
• Third Visit (July 8, 2024): As the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha, he visited relief camps in Jiribam, Churachandpur, and Moirang, and met with the Governor.
He still lost after Bharat Jodk whoch was a political stint and all sorts of anti India folks joined him along the way. Why did he not protest in Manipur like he is doing now ?
There is a reason he is keeping his mouth shut on Manipur. I am damn sure he knows something we don’t and if he opens his mouth on Manipur hidden things will come to light earlier than supposed to. Why is raga or any other opposition not saying anything on Manipur too? They don’t miss a chance to demean him and name call him right, why are they silent on Manipur too? Just like they are silent on FCRA too. Everything is wrapped under layers and layers and layers, all we can do is support the current gov till the next best thing comes up which keeps nation first
Tf is this defense you say "which keeps nation first" and then you are ready to ignore Manipur, even in this you end up questioning the opposition then something big is happening bla bla bla. I do not care whatev is the issue, Manipur is a border state it has been 2 plus years l, if we can have 26000 security in Delhi surely we can fix things in Manipur.
Ya I get you, I am not justifying the ignorance here by the current gov, what I am tryna say is we don’t know everything and we need to be a bit patient. I know this comment will also make u enraged but….
Say this to people who had to leave their houses and had their children burned - "this is something much deeper, you don't know anything, trust the current government"
Only reason why opposition silent on manipur is it doesnt help in elections. Avg Indian wont vote them over fighting for Manipur. Sad reality of citizens.
And FCRA story is diff.
Indira brought in FCRA to control US funding to JanSangh and RSS.
FCRA is already stringent enough currently. Separate accounts for foreign funds is maintained and all use is strictly audited
The new bill proposes to reduce jailtime for offences.
But it also proposes that if you run FCRA ngo, ut should continuously received funds and use it. If you dont, your license is cancelled.
And once cancelled, all stuff you did with foreign funds is under govt control automatically.
The main opposition is to this last thing. That lets say an NGO built a building in 1995 with FCRA funds. And for whatever reason they are no longer taking in foreign funds. Govt can cancel fcra license and take over the 1995 building.
If bill is updated to say that any stuff done from after bill applicable comes under this govt takeover purview, while earlier sruff wont, then most of opposition to it will stop.
Indira was bold in her decisions no denying that.
So is modi, apart from Indira only modi could have made the move of removing Article 370.
Also a pm who gives free hand to the army in response to terror attacks instead of holding them back or peace negotiations. If you can't acknowledge that you are simply blinded.
I mean, it’s only Modi who could have let Manipur burn, allowed the Chinese to occupy our patrolling posts, and then deny it ever happened.
Article 370 wasn't technically removed from the Constitution. What was removed was Jammu and Kashmir's special status under Article 370, turning it from a full fledged state into a UT with a Legislative Assembly. The Lt Governor now controls policing and public order, rather than the elected government.
And what exactly has this achieved for ordinary Kashmiris? Land ownership by outsiders is still subject to restrictions, there hasn't been the massive influx of investment or jobs that was promised, and Kashmiri Pandits haven't returned in any significant numbers. So what has it really achieved, apart from giving the government another political propaganda tool?
And what's this about the PM giving the army a free hand? Where did you even hear that? Because the last time I checked, there were serious questions about how Operation Sindoor was handled, the damage India suffered compared to Pakistan, and the extent of international support we actually had. Yet you're presenting it as some unquestionable military and diplomatic triumph.
So tell me, where exactly is this accountability you're talking about? Now we know his government is built on fraud, should he even be a PM? any man with honour would have resigned if his integrity was questioned to this level.
Integrating kashmir in India was a move which was bound to trigger both pakistan and china and bring in their retaliation.
Many kashmiri are very appreciative of Modi. Including muslims, in the recent protest a kashmiri muslim was beaten by the protesters because he was speaking in favour of Modi.
Integrating kashmir into India was a statement the previous governments feared to make.. Why should kashmiri have a special status if its supposed to be an integral part of India like the other states.
The free hand thing pretty sure was a statement by a army official after operation sindoor.
Many media covered it
Including the Hindu and NDTV.
You can look the articles up
You are inclined to believe what the pakistani government or media says rather than information from your owns country and army?.
Pakistani media has to make up something to calm down their public.
And what excuse they came up with?. They downed 2 rafales 😹.
Who knows how they downed jets if operation sindoor was done using Surface to surface ballistic missiles.
With no indian aircrafts involved.
Also give me the source of that chinese occupying indian petroling sites??
Let's focus on facts, I have linked the sources as hyperlinks.
Explain to me how has Kashmir been re-integrated to India and what has changed between before and after for both Kashmiris muslims, Kashmiri pandits and Indians from rest of the country?
Share me the source where the previous government feared integrating Kashmir?
and also why do states like Nagaland, Mizoram, Sikkim etc all have special statuses in Article 371?
The free hand thing pretty sure was a statement by a army official after operation sindoor.
Here is the rebuttal:
Captain Shiv Kumar, Defence Attache in Indonesia, said that the IAF lost jets in the early phase of Operation Sindoor as a result of restrictions imposed by the political leadership.
And what excuse they came up with?. They downed 2 rafales 😹. Who knows how they downed jets if operation sindoor was done using Surface to surface ballistic missiles. With no indian aircrafts involved.
Here is the rebuttal
The J-10s shot down at least one Rafale, Reuters reported in May, citing U.S. officials. Its downing surprised many in the military community and raised questions about the effectiveness of Western military hardware against untested Chinese alternatives.
Also give me the source of that chinese occupying indian petroling sites??
Here is the rebuttal
China's forces in the Galwan Valley have intruded 423 metres into Indian territory, an incursion which seems to be well ahead of Beijing's own 1960 Claim Line in the region.
Let's bust your logic. Since you've said why should kashmir get "special status". We it doesn't, let me ask you why should other stats get special status if they are also integral part of india?
Isn't uttarakhand, himachal pradesh, sikkim, meghalaya, tripura erc integral part of indian state also? Why are they having other forms of 370-371?
Was kashmir's special status revoked because it was a muslim majority? While other's special status remained because they are non muslims?
Dude the heroic work is done by the army, but the decision is taken by the govt. We're talking about a once in a generation fight event, not about everyday running of a sarkari office.
Well one would think that if they didn’t know the complete context of the prolonged delay during a fast moving crisis, leaving military commanders in a state of strategic limbo while Chinese troops consolidated their positions past the LAC. And it’s not an open hand as much as a passing on a political decision to the military command. Considering Modi claims he masterminded the Balakot strikes because he knew Paxtani radar wouldn’t detect Indian jets due to cloud cover, it’s a shame he didn’t have leadership to contribute when the enemy was upon us.
Just think about it, if pakistan is added to India, then they will be given voting rights according to constitution, and a huge population of India then will vote against Him, So ? Will he reside in that seat ?
Why would that happen? Has any government ever said we will add Pakistan back to India? What a stupid premise. POK has a very small population, not enough to have any sway of our national vote
He doesn't have the geopolitical clout needed to pull off something like that. I$®ael only managed it because of unwavering US backing, and even then, it cost them their geopolitical credibility.
Plus, he's no Indira Gandhi — he doesn't have the nerve to openly stand up to Western powers
hahah... peopel of india are having difficulty getting jobs... ab pok walon pehele tum jobs doge ...very good... althoguh gotta admit the peopel in pok will be more better represented in india than they are in pakistan
But seriously.. I am really worried that.. Before the elections BJ Pee Gobarmant is likely to start some Indo-Pak conflict that would get triggered by a suspiciously false-flag "terrorist attack."
And how does that changes the condition of middle class, lower middle class, the poor folks? How does it curb inflation and nonsense taxes? Would really appreciate an honest answer
As though this phattu will do that. Pakistan and Saudi signed thr joint defence pact. Delhi bladt happened after that and guess what? Not one bj party neta or godijivi said "pakisthan". Kyuki gand phati padhi thi unki.
Then you should be happy na...
Facing & handling these fake propoganda protests and still he captures pok.. that's a crazy a** thing to do..
If he done that I happily lean towards Modi's bakth
He has used army and Pakistan as a distraction every single time. I was wondering when the news channels would be talking about Pakistan and Aaj tak is ready with it.
And what will we do after capturing it? Complain it has muslims or our population has increased? Can't make a road or school worth a fcuk in the land we already have. Wants to capture some other terrority.
You're absolutely right bro.. These batads won't understand.. Modi is in the position of PM by the votes of such batads only.. And yeah they will of course downvote my comment but it's alright.. Cuz..
Yeah , just like 15lakh, 35rs petrol, rupee dollar same to same , 5 trillion dollar, 2 cr jobs, gst compensation cess, space tech roads, decriminalise politics, pollution free clean india. The list is endless indeed. Jaise ye sab aa gaya, POK bhi aa jayega.
Jhaatu se ladakh to sambhla nahi. Border se lakho rohingya jaan boojh ke le aya ki hinduo me darr paida ho sake. Gaay bhains export kar diye beef ke liye. Ram mandir loot liya
we can clearly see they arent, the roads have become worse, they have adulterated our fuel and more. what are they doing? again, its good if they do but i think that would js be purely to distract us from their shortcomings
Imagine if he takes POK but you still can’t drive because the roads are fucked, and Everything around you continues to get expensive, and your stocks continue to stagnate, and you income tax money is used to bail out Adani, your mother continues to cough from the winter pollution, and Manipur continues to burn.
Plot twist... The old trick of sending ED to harassed and letting Adani buying it for cheap isn't going to be applicable here. There will be armed opposition which the Delhi police wouldn't be able to lathi charge and arrest. Sorry it is a big.. No!
Modi will never do that, if you kept up to date even a bit about current affairs and geo politics you wouldn’t have said this.
POK is part of chinas CPEC project that is very essential to them. This project alone could save them Billions of dollars. Any threat to this project would be a direct threat to China which atm unfortunately India can’t afford. We can easily beat Pakistan it’s not something new that only Modi can do we’ve been doing it for years before him. The real test would be China for which Modi doesn’t have to balls.
He will win again. As of now, no one has more political experience and acumen than him. The only one closer to him is Amit Shah. Opposition knows this, hence they are creating unnecessary issues. Look at the all issues created in the last few years, all have fizzed down.
EVM hacking, ethanol blending, Modi is a CIA agent, Modi is a trump servant and now vote chori. This too shall pass.
I mean if refree herself/himself attests to wrongdoing directly or indirectly, winning this that is all a rhetoric (for more info read ECI press release)
ECI indirectly admitring that valid voters were deleted and that they made changes in Form 6 by adding declaration (which is unconstitutional btw. CEC doesn't have this power)
I believe central govt cant make changes to form 6 after consulting with EC.
Making changes in form is not unconstitutional
The changes they made in form 6 imo were mostly history related to voting
And if your name is deleted, you can definitely contest that part.
Court is yet to say that whether it was wrong or not.
It is unconstitutional. Making changes in form 6 falls under 1950 RP Act, which clearly states any amendments to the law and instruments related to rule requires Parliamentary (Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha) validation.
SC has clearly said that no approval was given from their side.
Bhai apni country toh sambhli nahi ja rahi issey and she's talking of about waging war against a nuclear powdered country and taking land away. Halva hai kya?
The economic and geopolitical consequences of such unprovoked actions would be far worse than even the current economic crises we're already in.
Touch some grass, brother. I'm well employed, and I actually left a well-paying government job in this government, specifically because I refused to blindly follow orders and be complicit in corruption.
•
u/AutoModerator 8d ago
Welcome to r/AllindiaStudentUnion!
This is a discussion space for everyone, covering everything from world to student trends.
Community Reminders: * Content Relevance: Ensure your content relates to India or has a documented impact on India within a global context (Rule 1). * Civil Discourse: No hate speech, identity-based attacks, or harassment (Rule 3). * No Spam: Do not turn the sub into a personal billboard or dump links without engaging (Rule 4).
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.