This is a discussion space for everyone, covering everything from global politics to student trends.
Community Reminders:
* Content Relevance: Ensure your content relates to India or has a documented impact on India within a global context (Rule 1).
* Civil Discourse: No hate speech, identity-based attacks, or harassment (Rule 3).
* No Spam: Do not turn the sub into a personal billboard or dump links without engaging (Rule 4).
Hindu-Muslim was there before BJP and will be there after BJP. Partition happened before BJP. Massacres in Naokhali, Kashmir, Malabar, Amritsar, Lahore, KPK etc etc happened before BJP.
Ha ha saudi bhi to andhelaudo ka desh hai isiliye to tumare bap porkiyo or kanglu ke immigrants ko nhi rakh rhe kyuki unko pata hai desh ki ma chod denge jese abhi uk france Germany ki chodi hai..lekin ap to mulle hai aap to nhi smjoge kuch har baar RSS HINDU OR BJP ki hi galti hai..
Har Baar, RSS, Hindu aur BJP ki galti nhi hoti.
Galti toh Muslims ki bhi hoti hain. Taali ek haath se nhi bajti.
Mera baap Indian hain.
UK, France, Germany...kya hi bolu abh. Jaisi news waise views.
Saudi k log nhi waha ka Ruler andhal'*&@ hain.
You have to understand that the less secular a country gets the more religious extremists will be there in the country. Ideal secularism and religious extremism is inversely proportional speaking broadly. Terror attacks are common in even Gujarat even though muslim population is very low compared to other states and is filled with andhbhakts, if you knew even basic political science you would know this but sadly you are an andhbhakt too who wants to abolish or deport all muslims. Calling me muslim slurs will not work by the way, I'm not a Muslim and hate all religions equally.
Muslim population in gujarat isnt like 0.2% that you are referring it as low.
We have more of these cockroaches than we'd like. So please correct your facts. Also the terror attacks in gujarat have reduced vastly now that Congress isn't in power.
Moreover terrorism does have a religion. I have never heard that RSS members planned and bombed the shit out the city.
I don't stand by any extremists groups and I hate bajrang dal and RSS equally but at the very least they are not directly involved in anti national activities.
Nanawati-Mehta Commission: Appointed by the Gujarat state government, this commission investigated the tragedy and concluded in its reports that the burning of the S-6 coach was not spontaneous but a "pre-planned conspiracy" orchestrated by local conspirators. This aligns with the final verdicts in the criminal trials, where several individuals were convicted for their roles in the conspiracy.
Please get your facts correct. Also there is a ton of evidence that the cancer community stored a shit load of petroleum products at the nearby lodge which was later used in burning.
Yeah sure. Innocent Hindus for sure and later innocent Muslims but they started it like always.
Yess non3 of these were BJP. In fact bjp prominence grew after Ram mandir incident after 1990s if i understand. Now I don't have much issue with Ram mandir and everything religous going on BUT the party is super corrupt, doesn't care about it's citizen ever, (Few weeks ago, Yogi blurted out "Mai bhashad sunne ke mood me nhi hu" to he lady who lost his son in a fire incident in lucknow where ambulance took 1 HOUR to arrive, in a wrongly approved building) and no accountability and zero concern of citizen wellbeing, infrastructure development cause we are focusing on the wrong problems and have just ended up hating each other so much more and that my friend is partially BJP's fault because they DIRECTLY benefit from it, you can see it through media houses. All the media is owned by them, the narratives are bent around them and the things that can taint there corruption and wrongdoings are never made the issue on public media.
So you don't have the right to criticize BJP government?.
Everytime someone criticizes the government you label them anti-national or bring in the Hindu vs muslim issue.
Abd BJP brainwashing did lead to mob lynchings and attacks, equally as bad as the radical muslims.
Logical? Ye Kis rulebook ye moral book mein likha hai ki agar aek majority(80%+) religion ki khami nikal raha ho to dusre religion ki khami nikalni hai? Wo to women ke liye bhi bolta hai, jis prejudice mein unko Haryana(isska home state) mein treat kiya jaata hai. Ab tum log isme logical ye kahoge ki Men ke liye nahi bolta.
Tu kar hi same Cheez raha and judging others without getting into a rationale debate about whatever it is you wish to discuss or have a gripe with.
But, anyhoo. And agar generalising par baat karre Phir toh Aise koi bhi Term dedo and people having issues with you or assumed community is fair game then toh.
Koi bhi kisiko bas judge Karle without hearing the other party. But, yeah
Seem to be just a frustrated kid and using reddit for that. Suit your shot
I've never seen a Muslim bad mouth a Hindu before he has done anything. You guys start and then act like victims when some does what you did to them first
The actual prank would be a drunkard woke up one day with heavy hangover and started to talk nonsense that he has spoken to god blah blah and because he was in somewhat position of power people listened to him and to prevent any other rise like this he banned alcohol. Everything is based on a man's dream. Kya has raha hoye ga voh abhi
Bro there is no proof that any of your gods existed. I don't want to say anything bad because I respect your religious sentiments. Bro I would answer any question you have but even if I gave you answers, you will still shit talk because you don't think logically.
Are u sure u dumb fuh krisna actually existed from yadu leniage and this started after the ancestor worshipping of yadu leniage. There are literally inscription and 5 ancestors of vrishni clan there names are engraved in well and there are other proves too. Rather yall just had a dream and banned alcohol so others don't experience this shi. You are taking about logic? 🤣 imagine being one of the youngest religion yet is oblivious to the earth, cosmos
"there is no widely accepted archaeological or historical proof that definitively demonstrates Krishna or Hanuman existed as historical individuals." Bro your religion is about teaching morals and human values through stories but those stories are not true that's why Hinduism is considered a mythological religion.
Bro alcohol is not allowed since it is an intoxicant and has severe effects on human body. Islam is a religion of logic, you have answers to any doubt and we are encouraged to question it. In your religion if I ask scientific or logical question people would frame me as anti-hindu or anti-national. Bro prophets before Muhammad PBUH like Moses, Jesus and Abraham all preached to believe in one true God. But the scriptures were corrupted so Quran is the final version.
If you have any doubt, you can just ask Chatgpt and tell it to give authentic sources, you don't even need to ask me. It would be more private also
Actual archeological proof of existence of lord krisna and lord Balaram this is the earliest known depiction. Read about yadu leniage and clan ancestors worshipping maybe u will get to know more.
While same cant be said about dat cause its just a fragment of imagination everything is built on a man's dream I don't take dream as actual proof plus everything is a mythology 🤣 do u even know the meaning of mythology ✌️😭
Firstly not your bro. Nah in actuality alcohol was banned so others can hallucinate about another revelation. Ohh is it based on logic that's why logically yall belive humans didn't go through evolution, logically deny human rights to women and dont even let them get educated, logically the earth is flat and dont get me started on the mythological story of how moon was broken into 2 pieces by a man on earth. The thing is yall build upon what the previous civilisation had already found out there is no major contribution even in the golden age. Logic should not be brought up by you.
scientific or logical question people
This applies to u perfectly i aint even gonna lie.
Who other belive this final book theory other than the people in the eco chamber. Btw read about param-brahma
If you have any doubt, you can just ask Chatgpt and tell it to give authentic sources, you don't even need to ask me. It would be more private also
Why dont you share me a link of your chat with chatgpt and I will talk with it and share it here again
Aur bhai 2iq bhi agar kis ke pass hoga toh woh usko pata rehga ki 1500 years pehle average age of marriage was 8-10 years in every religion. But aaj kon aisa nhi karta hai. Kyuki quran hi kehta hai ki agar jo country mein ho uska rule follow Karo. Aur india mein minimum age is 19 years I think. Toh woh follow kar sakte hai. Aur bhai prophet Muhammad PBUH ke dusre marriages dekh. Unhone widow se bhi shaadi kiye hai. Aur india mein widows ko fire mein marna padhta tha until 100years ago. Islam mein 4 marriages allowed hai only for this reason that during war if a husband dies a man can take care of the whole family. Ulta ye 4 marriages ke rules seh pehele log kitni bhi marriages karte the, tujhe toh pata hi hoga
Bro there is not a single Quranic verse that says marry children. Rather when to marry must be decided by maturity (according to Quran) which in today's world would be 22-24 years old. There is specific aayah that says "take consent of widows and virgins before marriage". Prophet Muhammad PBUH did not encourage to marry children/young women, his other wives were adults and also widows. Also Islam was the first religion/major religion to give women right of consent, if a women says no then one cannot force her into marrying. At that time women around the world did not have a say in marriages. Islam also encourages girl child, saying that properly carring for a girl will reward you with paradise and that a girl child is a blessing. In other parts of the practiced female infanticide. It still practiced in indian villages, especially in North, though it's greatly reduced now. Also people who promote this child marriages doesn't even have islamic knowledge. It's the same in Indian villages and Rajasthan that they conduct child marriages, so I can't say that hinduism promotes this, right? If you have any questions then you can directly ask chatgpt and ask it to quote Quran and authentic hadiths. You can clear any doubts or wrong perception you have, obviously if you want to.
Bro there is not a single Quranic verse that says marry children.
I dont care man , if its there in the quran or not, all i care is why is it just one religion , why only the islamic countries have legal age of marriage for girls below 18 , why the fk is it 13
I will get downvoted but it’s a fact that the left also suffers from selective criticism. Though, this video is not the right example to call out the hypocrisy.
I have seen lots of activists calling out how outdated many hind* religious practices are like Karva Chauth but they will not utter a word about how backward isla* is or speak against the practice of polygamy and the fact that isla* demands complete surrender to the faith.
Before you guys come at me, I don’t believe in any faith. I simply hate all forms of religious extremism, any person whose religion comes before rationale, logic and humanity is something I will never stand for be it a hind* or musli*.
When we selectively call out archaic values and beliefs we are simply contributing towards hate, religious divide and making the society more polarised which it already is.
The topic polygamy in Islam has a completely different context. It doesn't simply tell a practising muslim man to go out there and marry 4 women. As if there are 4 women ready to marry a single man, especially in the current age. What you are talking about is an extremely rare occurence.
If that were a mandatory and common practice then every other married muslim man would've had atleast 2 wives.
Also you cannot have partial faith. You either believe it or not.
I never said how many many people are participating in those rituals also if we are putting context behind every unreasonable practice than almost everything can be justified all customs will have to be permitted be it child marriage or Sati pratha.
That’s precisely my problem with faith, when you say you can’t practice faith partially that means you are prioritising religion before reason and that is something which doesn’t sit right with me.
I read that ‘Custom’ is also one of the sources and form of law but one of the essentials for a custom to be considered as a law is it should be reasonable, this made some sense to me and the same should be with all forms of religion.
As long as a religion allows you to be reasonable first, it’s fine with me but if it says faith is primary and reason, logic is secondary then I would just call it enslavement be it Hind* or Musli*.
Simple answer - an Ex-Hindu will criticise Hinduism, an Ex-Muslim will criticise Islam and an Ex-Christian will criticise Christianity. What you see as trending or a flaw is simply the representation of demography. In a Hindu majority nation most Atheist people will be Ex-Hindu, similarly you can checkout American Atheism, they will be spending most of their time criticising Christianity.
First you need to read the comment again. An Atheist is a person who rejects the idea of god regardless of religion and I never disagreed with it because I’m an Atheist as well. My statement was to educate that people will criticise the religion they identified with in the past or grew up in because that’s what they’ve experienced the most, that’s what they know the most about, they’ve seen what effect that particular religion and its teachings have on people or how people interpret the religious texts. How it shapes the cultural and societal values. Idk what you’re on about.
Bhai sach me Jhahilta or bewkoofi ki had hoti I show the comments are kaise chutiye log hai smj nhi ata inko har bar bs RSS BJP HINDUS RSS BJP HINDUS unko hi blame krte or protest me bhi kon ate hai sale mulle jinke khud ke bache panchar or chicken samose ki redi lagate hai...Kisiko criticize krna hai to kro hindus or rss kaha se aa gya bich me..salo ko na khana hajm hota hai na nind aati hai hindus ka nam liye bina..bc ye sale kabhi barabari nhi kr skta na hindus ki nahi RSS ki..gand fat jati hai jb samne ate hai to salo ki..
Are salo ki gand fat ti hai nile kabutaro ki mullo se and in mullo ki RSS se isiliye to hr jagah unka nam leke badnam krte hai..pr inko pata hi nhi hai in mullo k bap congress se kuch nhi hua RSS or hindus ka to ab to akele hai kya lund hoga..
Haan, bas aur kaato video ko. Sirf 2 sec "Allah" rakho aur bahut uksao logonko ki India Pakistan 2.0 banega. Kya kar rha h Amit Shah. Immediate action kyu nhi h. Kyu ki biased court mein bhi nhi chalega pura video dikhake. Bas ghumao or fear mongering karo.
So, for stability, put all the issues under the rug? Let us solve through voting? And the law that shields Chief election commissioner from any kind of legal oversight, which lets him do anything he wants without consequence is correct? The law that CEC can be selected by executive is correct? And the elections are fair? What avenue exists to express dissent and show problems anymore? Show me one avenue where government listens to people?
Stability is not more important than democratic norms and processes. In the name of stability and national security, this government stifled voices of the people. What happens is powerful people take control and win elections, there will be nothing you can do. You might ask, what's wrong with that. If you have a road that hasn't been repaired in a few years or decades, who will listen to you? The problem is the government refuses to see the problems/issues plaguing the country. When pointing out problems is equated with the Anti-nationalism, how can any problem be identified and solved. Gadkari's personal benefit wala Ethanol is a example. How are you supposed to argue against it. Cuz elections aren't fought on the basis of issues anymore, it's just security every time (cuz it's never fixed) and as such actual issues are never solved.
Sab issue me hindu muslim ka mamla daal do aur op jaise dalle 2 kaudi ke andhbhakt us baat ko leke daunde lagenge, original issue ko sab bhul jayenge. Kya badhiya cheat code nikala hai bjp ne.
They couldn't find any legit reason to demean and discredit the CJP protest. Their only way to bring it down is to dig into past interviews of members.
Udaipur tailor ke liye protest kyo nahi kara....
Dono criminal ko punish aur capital punishment nahi mila abhitak...?!))
Lekin neet aspirants to gayab ho gaya he...?/
Protest Kyo nahi hota jab qadir aur qadir punishment dictate karte h...!?/)
Biased protest h, teachers gayab h , students aur parent gayab h...?!/
Koi majahb se h
Koi lgtbq community
Koi neet aspirants ka bf h....(/??
Even doctor and proofessors of medical University are not present in protest...!//?
Hijacked to target one party and one religion...?//
How is this relevant to the demand for resignation of an incompetent and corrupt minister who failed the nation and its students?
But this BJP is so arrogant they won't admit their mistakes.
Definiton - Terrorism is
the unlawful use of violence or intimidation against civilians or governments, designed to create fear and advance a political, religious, or ideological cause. While there is no single universally agreed-upon international definition, it generally involves three core elements: the threat or use of violence, a calculated intent to create extreme fear, and the pursuit of a specific goal.
Why is it that of all the youth instead of "secular towards all religion" only "secular towards Hinduism" youth appears on social media. I condemn all religions for doing wrong things and so do most of my peers, but the Interviews on internet are from islam loving youth. Is this selective hatred and misguidance? Or is collective of youth only hating Hinduism.?
Indians are doomed to suffer ...u people can't see beyond religion, caste and geographical boundaries..Atleast do ur research before posting...people like u deserve to suffer ...people like sonam wangchuk should stop protesting and let people suffer ...evry woke people should jst leave India cuz Indians does not deserve anybody standing up fr them ..And that bihar reporter or any person who ever tried to make the lives of Indians better and died , I am Sorry that u were born among these spineless creatures..... Even I am useless, I am not doing anything to support sonam wangchuk or any activists who trying make this country a better place ...why these people don't get support because we Indians love to live in a hell.
"The thirsty travelers abandon the well to wage a war over the true shape of the mirage on the horizon. They die of thirst in the sand, proudly clutching the banners of two rivers that never flowed." - Gaudapada
first of all that's not even a good point that's he was talking about, like brochacho they protesting about something wayyyy more important and you care about some people praying ?
and the other things is, he's just larping atp.
like what he's saying is just bullshit, I don't even need to explain why.
but still he's wrong bcz, he said that why muslims are playing but other religions are getting critisiced.
but brother nobody is stopping anyone from doing religious activities and the people who were making fun of your religion, they are responsible not another religion's people.
he was literally saying that they should not pray. even thought everyone is allowed to pray there.
Chuitya madarchod bhadwe atheist wo hai tere ko kon ruk Raha hai religious hone mein? Yeh hi to democracy hai gadhe ki aulad, lekin tu je to dictators ke lund chusna hai isliye tujhe lagta hai agar neta jo kahe usi ko follow kar na hai personal matters mein, religion personal hota hai, lekin agar koi ake bole mein hindu hu tu bhi ban, mein muslim hu tu bhi Maan, mein atheist hu tu bhi ho ja tab wo dictatorship ho jata hai , gadhe ki aulad tu sala khoon ke ulti karke maar jata kyu nehi hai, sale madarchod
If the government in India was run by Muslims and the top seats werent taken by the so called Hindu high castes, and votes were collected in the name of Allah instead of Ram and mandirs, I think all the people asking why people werent talking about allah would get their answer, how can people be so dumb? lmao
Sonam Wangchuk is a Communist, charged with NSA (National Security Act) for instigating VioIence & currently on Bail.
Protest was for NEET exam paper leak however is hijacked by Communists like Brinda Karat, Suzanna Arundati Roy, Prakash Raj, Swara Bhaskar, father of Umar Khalid, LGBTQ & many more like them.
There are barely any people left in the Flop Protest and Oscar winning performance by Abhijeet Dipke has turned it into a Meme Fest on Social Media.
People only come when breakfast, Lunch snd Dinner is served by Junnaid who has alleged connections with AIMIM & supported Convicted TAHIR HUSSAIN for 2020 Delhi Tragedy of IB officer Ankit & is protesting in every protest like a rebel without a cause.
The goal post of the protest had changed and derailed from its objective NEET exam paper leak protest.
Did you care about the protest even at the initial stage? Maybe it wouldn't get "hijacked" if your beloved leaders showed even the slightest acknowledgement of their fault. It wouldn't get "hijacked" if they at least made an effort to have a word with Wangchuk.
As for calling Wangchuk a "Communist, charged with NSA", I wonder why the NSA charge was suddenly dropped after the Supreme Court criticised the "evidence" the Centre produced:
There is certain malice if the transcription of a 3-minute speech runs for 7-8 minutes, the Supreme Court has said, pulling up the Centre over the translation of activist Sonam Wangchuk's speech, based on which he was arrested in September.
Don't know whether you are brainwashed or simply a paid troll. If you're the former, individuals like you clearly show the sorry state of our education system. Learn to read and think for yourself before you jump to vomit your "opinions".
Being right winger doesn't mean you'll label everyone who's against BJP a communist. You clearly haven't heard or read of Wangchuk apart from pro-BJP social media posts
Let me break this bubble of yours- the avg Indian does not care about the cjp.
The auto driver, the rickshaw puller, the construction worker, the doctor working 92 hrs shifts at a stretch, the factory worker. None!
They are the majority of the votebank. Not even NEET aspirants care. Look at Allen and other institutions, NEET kids are studying there, oblivious of Dipke and Wangchuk.
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 15 '26
Welcome to r/AllindiaStudentUnion!
This is a discussion space for everyone, covering everything from global politics to student trends.
Community Reminders: * Content Relevance: Ensure your content relates to India or has a documented impact on India within a global context (Rule 1). * Civil Discourse: No hate speech, identity-based attacks, or harassment (Rule 3). * No Spam: Do not turn the sub into a personal billboard or dump links without engaging (Rule 4).
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.