r/pcmasterrace • • 1d ago

Meme/Macro Let's check it out on Github

Post image
17k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

207

u/C6500 7950X3D | 4090 | 32GB DDR5-6000 28-35-35-59 1d ago edited 1d ago

The UI thing is so important, yet a lot of open projects suffer from this.

There's also SolidCraft on Github now, it's a few days old and a decomp/rebuild of Fusion360.
Not the same devs, but the same concept.

Of course it's extremely new and a lot of stuff isn't working yet, but it's already more useable than FreeCAD ever was in 20(?) years of development because it's UI is so shit.

68

u/tangentandhyperbole 22h ago

China is way ahead of us on this. ZWCAD is literally a clone of Autocad and offers a perpetual license. They have their own version of Revit I haven't messed with.

35

u/PleiadesMechworks 17h ago

ZWCAD is literally a clone of Autocad

Turns out "development" is a lot easier when you just copy someone's homework

34

u/AdLocal1490 14h ago

Sounds very similar to american industrialists with things like the automobile and the train.

Nobody accuses Henry ford of being a thief despite all the theiving and copying he did.

I wonder what the difference is 🤔

11

u/dib1999 Ryzen 5 5600 // RX 7700XT // 32 gb DDR4 3600 MHz 13h ago

Socialism bad. But also please Daddy Gubmint, restrict their ability to compete in a free marketplace! They're using my idea!!!

5

u/Onaliquidrock 19h ago

Yea, they know how to steal

3

u/AdLocal1490 14h ago

Just like every American industrialist

7

u/mopthebass 1d ago

lot of stuff isn't working

Id rather spend more time wrestling with the design than wrestling with a slop machine

11

u/sartres_ 3950x | 3090 | 128GB 3600Mhz DDR4 22h ago

That'd be fair if FreeCAD wasn't also riddled with bugs, but it is. I don't care about a photoshop ripoff because there were already several good alternatives, but a usable OSS CAD program could really go places.

1

u/vladi_l 20h ago

I was supporting affinity back when it costed money, it only fell short in a big company setting, where you needed a 100% compatible psd file

Affinity makes usable ones, but text and vectors get rasterizes, which is usually fine for artwork, my main freelance use, but when it came to graphic design with heavy collaboration, I couldn't have my coworkers make concession

I still prefer working in it, over Photoshop + illustrator + InDesign, tge fact it's now one combined package is very convenient

4

u/as4500 Laptop G15AE 6800M 32GB@3600mt 1d ago

👍

1

u/The16BitGamer 16h ago

I do cad work and use FreeCad, this software looks like a proper CAD software but it isn’t.

It’s laggy, inaccurate and is missing so many features especially in the sketcher that it’s borderline unusable.

I think a lot of these “reverse engineer” efforts are just; take screenshots and describe what’s happening and slop out the result. I also tried effectscraft for a bit but each iteration is slowly breaking down and it’s not getting better

1

u/zaque_wann i7 6700HQ | GTX 1060 3GB | 8GB RAM 16h ago

I mean, if UX designers aren't willing to work for potentially free (donations aren't reliable to make freelance/comtract work possible) like devs do, its not exactly the devs fault.

1

u/_rikkss 15h ago

A lot of open source devs are just that, developers. They care about and know how making a functional thing, but generally lack good UI/UX experience or the motivation to put time under it.

Good thing about open source is though, that someone who bothers to deal with UI/UX can always help out!

1

u/Cautious-Extreme2839 11h ago

Fusion360 personal is literally free though?

1

u/C6500 7950X3D | 4090 | 32GB DDR5-6000 28-35-35-59 11h ago

Only for non-commercial use.

Which is fine by me as i'm only using it as a hobbyist anyway.
But Autodesk also is clamping down more and more on the free version. It's limited to 10 active projects (just a useless annoyance though) and it is missing some cool features that would be very helpful (e.g. when converting meshes to solid bodies).

2

u/ukezi 10h ago

Also the free version of Fusion a few years ago could do more then the current version and frankly I don't trust Autodesk at all to not suddenly want money for more basic functionality.

1

u/ukezi 10h ago

There's also SolidCraft on Github now, it's a few days old and a decomp/rebuild of Fusion360.

It looks like Fusion but is build on Nvidia's SMLib, or more exactly, a Rust port of it.