r/HomeImprovement • u/LabChowChow • 8h ago
Had house foundation repaired, which left dirt around perimeter of house. One side of house is within neighbor's yard, and they want the dirt to be removed/level with her yard, but workers said dirt needs to stay there to let it naturally settle.
TL;DR - Foundation repairs left dirt on side of house that is in neighbor's yard. Neighbor wants dirt to be leveled and her rock garden replaced, but I've been told that the dirt needs to stay as it is. Can the dirt be redistributed without ruining the foundation repairs? If not, is there a way to level out that area without adding a bunch of dirt?
Full background: I had my house's foundation repaired, as well as some other house work, all coordinated by my uncle helping out. The foundation repairs required the workers to dig around the perimeter of my house. This left about 1ft of dirt around the skirt of the house, sticking up from ground level by about half a foot. I'd been told that this is normal.
The problem is that the right side of my house's perimeter is within my neighbor's yard, so the workers needed to access her back yard in order to work on that side. However, in the process, they had dug up her rock garden she had laid out in front of her patio, which consisted of a layer of pea pebbles, weed barrier lining, and brick stepping stones.
Drawing of how our houses are laid out: https://imgur.com/a/3mtlDOp
Because the dirt stands higher than the rest of her yard, the neighbor wants the dirt to be leveled out, and have the lining and pebbles replaced. I asked one of my uncle's workers if the dirt could be moved or redistributed, and they said it could be. I offered to redistribute the dirt on that side to level it with the yard and to replace the lining and pebbles with Home Depot supplies, which the neighbor agreed. I scheduled some days that I'd come over and had just bought the pebbles and lining last night.
Come today, my uncle tells me that the dirt actually can't be moved and needs to be left alone so that it can over time settle naturally and level itself out (apparently the worker didn't know what he was talking about). I've messaged the neighbor that I can't move or level out the dirt and if that would be a problem. I'm currently waiting for her response. My uncle is being rather abrasive and is basically saying to tell the neighbor "tough luck."
What are my options here? My neighbor was concerned about water pooling up in her yard due to the height difference with the dirt. I'm still planning to lay out new weed lining and replace the pebbles, but the unleveled dirt is now a problem. If I need to leave the dirt alone and keep it unleveled, what should I tell my neighbor?
EDIT: The reason I posted to this sub and thought that my uncle's claim that the dirt can't be moved had any weight was because of this old post I had found:
https://www.reddit.com/r/HomeImprovement/comments/eg066c/foundation_repairedwhats_with_the_dirt/
A number of comments on this post were saying that leaving the dirt like that and letting it settle is common.