My wife and I lost our new dachshund puppy, Buttercup, or “Butters” as we called her, yesterday in a horrible accident, and I’m having an incredibly hard time processing it. I feel like I failed her.
We already have four dogs, including two dachshunds who are 2 and 4 years old. While we were away on our anniversary trip, we came across a dachshund puppy online with heterochromia (two different colored eyes). She was from the same breeder as our other two dachshunds. We’d always said that if we ever found one with two different colored eyes, we’d have to get her. We weren’t necessarily planning on getting another dog, but when we saw her, it just felt meant to be.
We named her Buttercup, but quickly started calling her Butters.
She was just starting to settle into our family. She had gotten comfortable sleeping in bed with us through the night, without any potty accidents. She would hold it as long as she could because all she wanted to do was cuddle up and sleep. She was such a sweet, sleepy little thing.
Our other two dachshunds were also finally starting to open up to her. They were beginning to play and roughhouse together, and it was so exciting watching her become part of their little pack.
I work from home, so even though we’d only had her for a short time, we’d already spent so much time together. She was getting really attached to me and wanted to be wherever I was.
For some background, I own a small mushroom farm. Along with growing mushrooms indoors, we cultivate shiitake mushrooms outdoors on hardwood logs. We soak these logs in water and then stack them to encourage the mushrooms to fruit.
I’ve always let our dogs follow me around while I’m working outside. They love exploring the property and keeping me company, and it’s something we’ve done countless times over the years without an issue. I was so excited for Butters to grow up doing the same thing, becoming my little work companion. She was already doing so well following me around.
Yesterday was just another normal day on the farm.
I had originally left her upstairs with the other dogs, but she was whining because she wanted to be with me. We’d spent so much time together since bringing her home, and I didn’t want her to feel left out or upset. So I let her come outside and follow me around while I worked, just like our other dogs have always done.
I was taking shiitake logs out of their soaking tank and stacking them nearby. Toward the end, one of the logs fell from the stack. It startled Butters, and she ran around to the other side of my truck.
I didn’t want her to be frightened, so I went back and restacked the logs, making sure they were more secure, or so I thought. I’ve worked with these logs for years and have never had a stack collapse like this before.
She was about ten feet away from the stack when I finished. I turned around to continue emptying the soaking tank, and seconds later I heard the logs fall again.
I knew almost instantly something was wrong.
I turned around expecting to see her running away scared again, but instead I saw her on the ground having what looked like a neurological reaction. I immediately picked her up. Blood was coming from her nose, one of her eyes was protruding, and I could feel that her skull had been fractured.
In a matter of seconds, I went from thinking I needed to rush her to the emergency vet to realizing there was nothing I could do.
I completely lost it.
My wife and I spent the rest of the evening crying. We buried our little Butters that night.
I cannot stop replaying those few minutes in my head.
Why didn’t I just leave her upstairs with the other dogs? She was safe up there. She was finally getting comfortable with them, and they were starting to play together. She would have been perfectly fine if I’d just let her whine for a little while.
Why did I let her follow me around while I was moving logs? Why didn’t I take the first falling log as a warning? Why didn’t I move her farther away?
There are so many little decisions I could have made differently, and any one of them might have meant she’d still be here.
The worst part is that I was trying to make her feel safe. When the first log fell and scared her, I wanted to show her everything was okay. I genuinely thought I’d secured the stack. I never imagined something like this could happen.
I’ve spent years doing this work with my other dogs wandering around me. It was such a normal part of our lives that I never really considered something like this happening.
And now I keep thinking about all the little things we were just beginning to experience with her. How she’d started sleeping through the night with us, how attached she was becoming, how our other dachshunds were finally accepting her. She was just starting to understand that this was her home and we were her family.
She was supposed to have years of sleeping in our bed, playing with her siblings, and following me around the farm.
Instead, we barely got to know her.
I know it was an accident. I know I would never intentionally put her in danger. But I was responsible for keeping her safe, and I can’t shake the feeling that I failed her.
She trusted me. She wanted to be near me so badly that she cried when I left her upstairs, and I keep coming back to the fact that if I’d just let her stay there, she’d probably still be curled up in bed with us right now.
I’ve lost pets before, but I’ve never experienced anything like this. The suddenness, witnessing it happen, and knowing that a different decision on my part could have prevented it is absolutely eating me alive.
I don’t really know what I’m looking for by posting this. Maybe I just need to get it off my chest and talk to people who understand how deeply losing an animal can hurt, especially when you’re struggling with guilt.
I just wish I could go back to yesterday, leave her upstairs with her siblings, and come home from working to find her waiting for me.
I would give anything to have our little Butters back.